Government attorneys contend that even with the error, U.S. courts lack the authority to facilitate the release of Kilmar Abrego Garcia.
Donald Trump’s strict immigration policies came under renewed examination on Tuesday when authorities acknowledged that a “clerical mistake” during the hasty deportation procedures led to the wrongful transfer of an individual to a well-known detention facility in El Salvador.
The Trump administration promotes its extensive initiative against immigrants – a major campaign pledge – as an effort to target gang members and other violent offenders.
However, numerous assertions that several people with tenuous or no links to organized crime have been swiftly expelled have sparked outrage among human rights organizations, Democrats, and even certain Trump supporters, such as the prominent podcaster Joe Rogan.
A man from El Salvador resided in the U.S. state of Maryland under protected legal standing until he was transported to El Salvador along with several hundred other individuals accused of being gang members in mid-March, according to a court document released on Monday.
The aircraft arrived shortly following Trump’s invocation of a seldom-used wartime measure, the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, even though a judge had instructed to stop these deportations.
In 2019, Kilmar Abrego Garcia faced accusations of being part of a gang; however, he wasn’t found guilty of any offenses. A judge had earlier ruled against his deportation, fearing potential harm to him in El Salvador.
In the court documents submitted on Monday, attorneys for the government acknowledged that he was sent back due to an “administrative mistake,” yet they contended that U.S. courts currently lack the authority to ensure his liberation.
When pressed on the topic on Tuesday, the White House stood firm, asserting that undisclosed evidence indicated Abrego Garcia was actually a key figure in the vicious MS-13 gang.
The Salvadoran group along with others like Venezuela’s Tren de Aragua has been labeled as “foreign terrorist organizations” under President Trump’s administration.
“The United States of America no longer offers legal protection to foreign terrorists, and President has both the executive authority and power to remove these reprehensible individuals from our communities,” said White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt at a briefing.
A distinct instance of a gay barber who was deported has drawn attention from U.S. media outlets, and attorneys representing multiple individuals facing deportation claim that their clients were singled out solely due to their tattoos.
Rogan, who supported Trump during the 2024 election, stated on Saturday that it was “horrible” that individuals not involved in criminal activities might get caught up in the efforts to remove gang members from the country.
“The fear arises as even non-criminals are being apprehended, deported, and end up in El Salvador prisons,” stated the comedian and mixed martial arts analyst.
Let’s remove the gang members. Everyone is on board with this. However, we shouldn’t include innocent gay hairdressers with these groups.
The US Vice-President, J.D. Vance, addressed the topic on social media on Tuesday, subsequently making several corrections after noticing inaccuracies in his initial postings.
Initially referring to Abrego Garcia as a “convicted MS-13 gang member,” he subsequently stated that an immigration judge had “concluded” he was part of MS-13, adding that “any ‘due process’ he was owed, he got.”
The activation of the ancient AlienEnemiesAct has ignited intense discussions among legal experts regarding immigrants’ entitlement to fair procedures and the degree to which courts can scrutinize decisions made by government officials.
On Friday, the Trump administration requested the Supreme Court to reverse the federal judge’s suspension of deportations carried out under that specific authority.
Stephen Miller, Trump’s deputy chief of staff and a strong adversary of unlawful immigration, has consistently criticized the judge’s moves as a danger to democratic principles.
“A kind reminder: if you have unlawfully entered our nation, the sole ‘procedure’ you’re entitled to is deportation,” he stated on social media Tuesday.
More Articles from SCMP
Beijing shifts exercises nearer to Taiwan, researcher appeals to China via AI: SCMP daily roundup
During the tariff conflicts, Chinese automobile manufacturers are taking over the Russian market.
Could new US tariffs on China be ‘too significant to handle, too obvious to evade’?
“Jimmie Lau Lane”: U.S. urged to name D.C. street after imprisoned businessman for Hong Kong trade office location
The article initially appeared on the South China Morning Post (www.scmp.com), which is the premier source for news coverage of China and Asia.
Copyright © 2025. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.